Why are apostles speaking "in their own tongues" accused of being drunk?
Welcome to Ask Pastor Randy, a blog by Pastor Randy Schutt of Shepherd of the Valley Lutheran Church. Ask your own question here.
Question
I have a question about Pentecost. If the apostles are speaking in other languages that the various people can hear and understand "in their own tongues", why are they accused of being drunk? (I've never heard of drinking too much making it so that the drinker can suddenly be fluent in a foreign language.)
Pastor Randy Responds
Commentaries I have read don't say much about this, so I think the point is, that the "new wine" comment is made by people who can't understand what the disciples are saying, to them another language sounds like jibberish, so they figure they must be drunk.
Question
I have a question about Pentecost. If the apostles are speaking in other languages that the various people can hear and understand "in their own tongues", why are they accused of being drunk? (I've never heard of drinking too much making it so that the drinker can suddenly be fluent in a foreign language.)
Pastor Randy Responds
Commentaries I have read don't say much about this, so I think the point is, that the "new wine" comment is made by people who can't understand what the disciples are saying, to them another language sounds like jibberish, so they figure they must be drunk.
You are right in saying that someone who is drinking doesn't suddenly become fluent, instead they become more difficult to understand (slurred, unsteady words, etc.). Critical listeners of the disciples blamed them (the disciples) for their own (critical listeners) inability to understand.
Hope that makes sense.
Pastor Randy




